Put proposals on the same footing
Two quotes can have similar prices while covering very different work. Before comparing them, write down the problem you asked suppliers to solve, the expected output and the period covered. Check whether each proposal describes the same services, locations and customer journey. If one supplier recommends a different approach, ask it to explain why and what it has left out.
Use a simple comparison sheet with one row for each requirement. Mark an item as included, excluded or unclear instead of assuming silence means inclusion. Send the same clarification to each supplier. A clear answer about a limitation is more useful than a broad promise that everything is covered.
Look beyond activity counts
A proposal might list articles, social posts, website changes or technical checks. Counts help describe capacity, but the purpose and quality of each item matter too. Ask who researches and approves the work, how customer questions influence it and what happens if the evidence suggests a different priority. A fixed volume is not automatically useful if nobody can maintain or approve it.
For search work, ask what changes will be made, which pages are involved and whether recommendations include implementation. Clarify what the supplier needs from you. Be cautious about assurances of a guaranteed search position: visibility depends on factors outside any supplier's control, and a sensible plan should explain its uncertainties.
Understand fees and dependencies
Distinguish a one-off setup fee, recurring service, advertising spend and third-party software. Ask whether quoted amounts include applicable taxes and any unavoidable charges. Check whether a proposal assumes you will supply photographs, write technical material, approve content quickly or purchase a separate tool. These assumptions affect the real workload and cost.
Ask what happens when the work takes longer than expected or the brief changes. A written change process can protect both sides: a proposed change should describe its effect on deliverables, timing and cost before it is agreed. Do not compare a partial first phase with a complete delivery as if they were the same scope.
Compare the complete proposal
- ScopeIncluded work and exclusions
- CostFees, software and advertising
- ControlAccounts, files and handover
- ReviewEvidence and next decisions
Clarify access and ownership
Agree who controls the domain, website, analytics account and creative files. You should understand what access the supplier needs, how it will be granted and how it will be removed at the end of the relationship. A shared password is not a sensible substitute for appropriate account permissions. Keep a record of the business owner for each system.
Ask what you can use or edit after the project, including copy, design files, photographs and any licensed software. Some materials may be subject to third-party terms. Make sure handover and support are described in the agreement rather than assuming that a completed website includes ongoing maintenance indefinitely.
Compare the reporting and review
Look for a reasonable connection between the proposed activity and a business outcome. A useful report might cover work completed, relevant enquiry patterns and an explanation of what will change next. Search traffic, clicks or followers may provide context, but none automatically represents a paying customer. A reporting schedule is valuable only if someone uses it to make decisions.
Ask what happens if the expected signal is unavailable, how enquiries will be classified and who checks data quality. Where numbers are small, a conversation about individual, properly protected enquiry patterns may be more useful than a dramatic percentage. Agree a review point and discuss what would justify continuing, changing or stopping the work.
An illustrative comparison
Imagine one proposal offers a website audit and a written list, while another includes an audit plus a limited number of agreed fixes. Both could be appropriate, but their prices should not be compared without recognising the implementation difference. Ask each supplier to identify excluded work, the person responsible for approvals and whether the website can be safely tested.
A third proposal may include regular marketing support but require a separate design fee. Record that difference and decide which arrangement fits the business's capacity. This is an illustrative example, not a recommendation for a particular provider or a statement about typical prices.
A practical comparison exercise
Make a table with the same rows for every proposal: investigation, implementation, content, testing, reporting, third-party fees, handover and ongoing support. In each cell write 'included', 'excluded' or 'clarify', then add the relevant page or sentence from the proposal. Do not award an item a tick merely because a heading uses a familiar phrase such as 'SEO package'.
For an imagined redesign, one supplier may include five page templates and content migration, while another includes the same number of templates but expects the business to move all content. Ask both to describe what happens to existing URLs and forms. The task is not to invent an average price; it is to compare the complete work and the time you must provide.
If you need an ongoing arrangement, compare the initial commitment, review interval, cancellation process and ownership of accounts. Ask what happens to unfinished work if the relationship ends. A short clarification can reveal an important difference before you make a commitment, and it also shows whether the supplier communicates in a way your team understands.
When a proposal contains a measurable target, ask how the baseline will be established and what qualifies as an enquiry or completed action. Distinguish an estimate from a contractual promise, and ask the supplier to identify factors outside its control. Record the answer in the same comparison sheet rather than assuming all suppliers use the same definition.
Make the selection practical
Use the same decision criteria for every supplier: understanding of your problem, clarity of work, relevant experience, ability to answer questions, ownership, realistic timing and total cost. Weight the criteria according to what your project actually needs. Request examples only where the supplier has permission to share them, and do not treat a polished presentation as proof of results.
Before work starts, confirm the deliverables, dependencies, payment terms, review process, exit arrangements and named contacts in writing. Retain the agreed proposal and any approved changes. If a term is unclear or material to your decision, ask an appropriately qualified adviser to review it before signing.
