Decide what the comparison should answer
A competitor review should inform a decision rather than create a long list of websites to imitate. Choose a question first: are visitors able to understand the type of work available, compare a service or find out whether an area is covered? For a business serving Hertfordshire, choose a small set of organisations that genuinely offer a similar service to a similar audience. Record the date and your selection criteria. A national directory or marketplace might also influence a customer's choice, even when it is not a direct local supplier.
Compare the offer accurately
Read each public service description as a prospective customer would. Record what is clearly stated about the type of work, the next step, the service area and any visible conditions. Do not assume that a business lacks a qualification or does not provide a service simply because you cannot find it on one page. Make separate notes for observed facts and questions that remain unanswered. A short comparison table with links to the public pages you reviewed is more useful than a verdict such as ‘their website is bad’.
A simple comparison might use columns for the audience described, the service offered, coverage, how to obtain a quote and the evidence visible on the page. Enter ‘not stated’ when information is absent rather than replacing it with ‘no’. Keep the page address and date alongside each observation. If one organisation offers a different service or serves a different audience, exclude it from a like-for-like comparison or label the difference clearly. You can then choose the questions worth answering on your own site without turning a limited review into a claim about the whole market. Review the notes with someone who understands the service before sharing conclusions internally.
Notice the customer's practical questions
Look at how a visitor can tell whether the offer is suitable: are typical projects described, is there a clear way to request information, and are important conditions available? Consider the task on a phone as well as a larger screen. Then compare those observations with questions that your own customers actually ask. A competitor's approach may suggest a question worth answering, but it does not establish that their wording or page structure is right for your audience. Check your own operational details before making changes.
A fair competitor review
- ObservedRecord what a public page actually says
- UnknownMark missing or unclear information
- OpportunityChoose a useful change you can deliver
- ReviewCheck the change against customer questions
Treat pricing and claims with care
Published prices may cover different work, dates, quantities or geographic areas. Record what is included and do not present a partial price as a complete comparison. If a price is not public, mark it as unknown. Likewise, a public review or a claim about delivery speed is not necessarily independently verified. Do not copy testimonials, images, logos, detailed text or customer lists into your marketing materials. When discussing a competitor publicly, avoid unsupported comparisons and check the rules applicable to any comparative advertising.
Find an opportunity you can deliver
After reviewing the information, identify one or two useful improvements you control. You might make it easier to understand how a quotation is prepared, publish accurate availability information or provide an accessible example of the work you actually do. An apparent gap in another website is only an observation; it does not prove that customers need the feature or that it will improve rankings. Discuss the idea with the team delivering the service and test whether the change solves a question your audience really has.
Prioritise the opportunity by checking three things: whether customers have actually raised the issue, whether you can give an accurate answer, and who will keep that answer up to date. A short explanation of how a quote is prepared may be more useful than adding a feature that no one in the team can maintain. Agree a review date and note what would cause the explanation to change. If the proposed improvement involves publishing a third party's material, check permission and the accuracy of the surrounding description first.
Keep a proportionate record
Use a shared sheet containing the source address, the date, the question you were investigating, the observation and the action you may take. Avoid storing personal details that are not needed. Give each action an owner and a review date so research does not become a permanent exercise in monitoring competitors. Recheck information before relying on it because services and pages can change. If you later use customer feedback, explain how it was collected and distinguish feedback from your interpretation.
Illustrative example: choosing a service-page improvement
Imagine a Hertfordshire home-service provider looking at three comparable public websites. Two explain that a survey may be needed before a quote; one does not explain its process. The provider's own team says that customers often ask the same question. A proportionate next step is to explain its actual survey process, including any conditions, rather than claiming a competitor does not offer surveys. The observations and business in this example are invented. They demonstrate a method and are not evidence about named local companies or measured results.
Treat search results as a changing view
Search results are one way to discover what someone might encounter, but the results you see can vary with the query, location, device and other context. Do not describe a single search as a permanent ranking or assume that one visible result explains another business's performance. Capture the query and date when a result is relevant to your review. Use it to understand what kinds of pages answer the question, then investigate your own offer and customer needs before deciding what to change.
A five-question review
Before acting, ask: does this source offer a genuinely comparable service; what did I actually observe; what remains unknown; is the proposed change useful to my customer; and can my business deliver what the new wording promises? Check that any image, claim or example you plan to use is yours to use and accurate. Then make one change and decide how you will review it. Competitor research can inform a better decision, but it cannot replace understanding the people you intend to serve.
